top of page
Bread and More Logo
SEARCH

Tunneling in Sourdough: What Those Giant Holes Are Telling You

Nov 2
5 min read

You bake a beautiful loaf of sourdough. The crust looks good, the scoring opened up, and you’re feeling pretty proud.


Then you slice into it.


There’s a hole big enough for your butter to fall straight through… surrounded by bread that feels heavy and dense. 😅

What happened?


Those oversized holes can be tunneling, and when they appear alongside a tight, dense crumb, they can be a clue that your dough needed more fermentation time.


Let’s talk about what you’re seeing, how a young starter can contribute, and what to adjust on your next bake.

Tunneling in Sourdough
Tunneling in Sourdough

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no additional cost to you and helps support Bread and More.


What Is Tunneling in Sourdough?


Tunneling describes unusually large, sometimes elongated air pockets inside your bread. You might see a few caverns near the top or irregular tunnels running through the slice.


The important part is what the bread looks like around those holes.


A well-fermented loaf can have an open crumb with holes of different sizes and still feel light throughout. Underfermented bread may have a few enormous holes surrounded by tight, heavy areas.


That combination is sometimes called “fool’s crumb,” because the large holes can initially look like a successful open crumb.


Big holes alone don’t tell the whole story. Look at the surrounding texture, too.


What Does Underfermented Bread Look Like?


When you slice your loaf, you may notice:

  • A few oversized holes surrounded by tightly packed crumb.

  • Long, irregular tunnels instead of air pockets distributed throughout.

  • A dense band toward the bottom.

  • Areas that feel heavy or gummy after the loaf has cooled.


The outside can be misleading, too. Some underproofed loaves spring up dramatically or burst through the crust. A tall loaf doesn’t automatically mean fermentation was right.


Think of it this way: you’re looking for bread that has developed lightness throughout the slice, not just a few impressive empty spaces.


Why Does Underfermentation Cause This?


During fermentation, microorganisms in your starter produce gas that your dough’s gluten structure holds.


If the dough hasn’t fermented sufficiently, much of it can still be tight and poorly aerated. Existing gas pockets expand during baking, but the loaf can finish with large cavities alongside dense areas.


Underfermentation can involve ending bulk fermentation too early, giving the shaped loaf too little final proof, or both. More time at the appropriate stage can improve that uneven crumb.


If those stages still feel confusing, start with my Fermentation Made Simple guide.


How a Young Starter Fits Into the Picture


A new starter can be bubbly before it becomes a dependable bread-raising partner.


One exciting rise doesn’t tell you as much as repeated, predictable rises after feeding. A starter that’s still developing may ferment dough more slowly than the established starter used by the person who wrote your recipe.


So you follow the recipe’s clock, shape the dough, and put it in the refrigerator—but your dough hasn’t reached the same stage.


The starter’s age matters less than how reliably it performs.


Look for a starter that repeatedly rises well after feeding, develops bubbles throughout, and has a pleasantly tangy aroma. Readiness can take longer than a recipe’s suggested timeline, especially in a cool kitchen.


My How to Make a Sourdough Starter From Scratch guide walks through the building process. Give yourself permission to spend longer on that step.


Your starter doesn’t know you planned to bake on Saturday. 😂


the cheese and jalapeños create additional pockets, making it harder to separate inclusion-related holes from fermentation issues.
the cheese and jalapeños create additional pockets, making it harder to separate inclusion-related holes from fermentation issues.

Tips to Help Prevent Tunneling


1. Track your starter before judging your dough


Use a clear starter jar, mark the level immediately after feeding, and record when it peaks.


Keep the feeding ratio and temperature consistent while you observe it. That makes changes easier to interpret.


A digital kitchen scale helps keep those feedings repeatable. Measuring by weight removes a variable when you’re troubleshooting.


For help choosing and understanding ratios, read Understanding Starter Ratios and Scaling Up Your Starter, or use my Starter Feeding Calculator.


2. Check your dough temperature


Your kitchen temperature is useful information, but your actual dough temperature tells you more.


Cold ingredients can leave you with cool dough even in a comfortable room. A digital probe thermometer makes that easier to spot.


Temperature also affects how much fermentation continues after refrigeration: warm dough takes time to cool down and keeps fermenting along the way. That’s one reason a single rise target won’t suit every method.


3. Watch for a combination of changes


Don’t make the decision based on one surface bubble.


During bulk fermentation, look for increasing volume, visible aeration, and a dough that feels noticeably puffier than it did after mixing. A clear container makes those changes easier to follow.


Use your recipe’s guidance as a starting point, then compare it with what your dough is actually doing.


4. Don’t assume every dough must double


The appropriate rise before shaping depends on your recipe, dough temperature, and what happens afterward.


If your loaf repeatedly shows signs of underfermentation, keep the recipe and temperature similar and allow a little more rise on the next bake. Record the result instead of making a huge timing change.


A small, deliberate adjustment teaches you more than changing everything at once.


5. Give dough development some attention


Fermentation and dough strength work together.


Mix thoroughly so the starter and salt are incorporated evenly, and follow your recipe’s mixing and folding method. If this step feels uncertain, read How to Mix Your Dough (and Why It Matters).


Adding more water isn’t the first thing I would change when troubleshooting giant holes and dense bread. First, make your process consistent enough to see what’s helping.


Does Every Giant Hole Mean Underfermentation?


No—and this is where troubleshooting gets interesting.


An isolated cavity in otherwise light bread can come from air trapped during shaping. Excess flour between folded layers can also interfere with those layers joining.


When shaping, use enough flour to handle the dough without burying it. Gently release unusually large visible bubbles instead of aggressively pressing all the air out.


Also, gumminess alone doesn’t prove underfermentation. Baking and cooling affect texture, too. Let the loaf cool fully before judging the crumb, and consider the whole process.

Large, irregular cavities surrounded by tighter crumb—a pattern that can indicate insufficient fermentation.
Large, irregular cavities surrounded by tighter crumb—a pattern that can indicate insufficient fermentation.


A crumb photo gives you clues. Your baking notes help explain them.


A Simple Plan for Your Next Loaf


Before starting over with a different recipe, try this:

  1. Use a starter that rises predictably after feeding.

  2. Keep the same flour, recipe, and feeding ratio.

  3. Record your dough temperature and starting level.

  4. Watch the dough’s development alongside the clock.

  5. Adjust one thing based on what the previous loaf showed you.

  6. Photograph the cooled crumb so you can compare your results.


You don’t need a perfect loaf to make progress. You need a little information from the last one.


And please remember: bread with a more even, smaller crumb can be beautifully fermented. Your sandwich does not require a cavern. Neither does your butter. 😉


If you’re building confidence, visit my Start Here guide for more sourdough lessons and information about learning with me.


Give your starter time. Give your dough attention. And give yourself some grace.



About the Baker


Hi, I'm Jenny, the baker behind Bread and More. I run a small microbakery where I bake sourdough breads, bagels, and baked goods for my community.


Here on the blog I share sourdough tips, baking lessons I've learned along the way, and simple guidance to help home bakers feel more confident baking sourdough.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page